Editorial process guide

1. Editorial Process for Research Articles

This section outlines the steps required to comply with the publication guidelines and the preliminary registration of research articles submitted for double-blind peer review.

1.1. Initial Submission and Verification

The editorial process begins with the submission of the article through the journal’s Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform. At this stage, the author must create an account on the platform, which will be used to manage the editorial process and communicate with the Editorial Committee and the specialists responsible for peer review. The author must also register the manuscript and attach the required supplementary documents:

  • Research article: A Word document prepared according to the template established in the guidelines.
  • Images and author photograph: Images included in the article must be submitted individually in JPG or PNG format at a resolution of 300 dpi. The author photograph must meet the same format and quality requirements.
  • Declarations and form: The required documents must be signed and uploaded in PDF format at the time of submission through the platform. The documents required for research articles are available here.

The Editorial Committee will conduct an initial review of the submitted documents to verify compliance with formal requirements, the relevance of the manuscript, and its conformity with the journal’s editorial guidelines. Research articles will also undergo a similarity check using Turnitin, which will examine matching text, its sources, citations, paraphrasing, and any potential improper reuse of the authors’ own texts. ANTEC allows a similarity index of up to 10%, excluding bibliographic references and properly cited text. This verification stage takes forty (40) calendar days.

If the specified similarity threshold is exceeded or deficiencies or omissions are identified in the submitted documentation, the manuscript will be returned to the author for the required revisions. The author must resubmit the corrected version through the platform within ten (10) calendar days of notification. If the requested corrections are not made, the author will be notified that the manuscript has been rejected.

1.2. External Peer Review

Once the manuscript has passed the initial verification stage, it will proceed to peer review. The Editorial Committee will appoint three (3) specialists based on the manuscript’s subject area. Double-blind peer review will be the default procedure. However, authors may choose single-blind or open peer review if their article has been deposited in a preprint server.

Reviewers will be notified through the platform and will have seven (7) days to accept or decline the review invitation issued by the Committee.

Reviewers will assess the manuscript’s methodological quality, argumentative coherence, currency of the bibliography, relevance of the findings, and scientific contribution. They will then provide their comments and recommendations.

At least two positive review reports will be required for the evaluation to proceed. Based on the reports received, the Editorial Committee will decide whether the article is accepted, accepted subject to revisions, or rejected. Articles accepted without revisions will automatically proceed to the next stage of the editorial process.

This stage will take fifteen (15) calendar days, from the date on which the selected reviewers accept the review invitation to the issuance of their verdict. Requests for extensions will be assessed by the Committee, which will decide whether to grant or deny them. Where necessary, a replacement reviewer may be appointed if the original reviewer is unable to complete the evaluation within the allotted time.

1.3. Revision of Review Comments and Copyediting

Articles accepted subject to revisions must incorporate the comments and recommendations made by the specialists during peer review. Authors must submit the revised version within fifteen (15) calendar days of notification.

Once the revised version has been received, copyediting and final review will take place. This stage includes checking spelling, grammar, and syntax; ensuring clarity of presentation; and verifying that the comments and recommendations issued during the academic review have been addressed. This stage will take ten (10) calendar days.

1.4. Editorial Production

Once the article has been approved, a preliminary version in Word format will be sent to the author for final review. The article will subsequently be made available through the OJS platform under the journal’s advance publication model, allowing the completed version to be registered and made accessible before its inclusion in the corresponding issue.

The author will have seven (7) days to review the final version, confirm approval, and submit any relevant comments, if applicable. Once approved, the definitive version will be registered in OJS as part of the article’s editorial history. The journal’s layout and typesetting process will then begin in accordance with its editorial guidelines.

1.5. Publication

Once the definitive version has been approved, the typeset article will be published on the journal’s Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform in various reading formats, as part of the scheduled volume and issue.

Upon final publication, the article becomes part of the scholarly collection of ANTEC and remains available online for consultation indefinitely. It is also shared through the UNM institutional repository.

The editorial process takes a total of one hundred and eighty (180) days, in accordance with the stages and deadlines established by the journal.

2. Editorial Process for Dossier Contributions and Reviews

This section establishes the guidelines for the submission, evaluation, and publication of contributions to the Dossier and Reviews sections. Participation in these sections is by invitation from the Editorial Committee or through a call for submissions. Submissions are subject to an administrative evaluation to determine their suitability for the relevant section.

  • Authors must submit their manuscripts through the journal’s OJS platform and attach the required supplementary documents, including images and author-signed forms, as applicable to the section in which they are participating.
    • Dossier contribution or review manuscript: A Word document prepared according to the template established in the guidelines.
    • Images and author photograph: Images included in the article must be submitted individually in JPG or PNG format at a resolution of 300 dpi. The author photograph must meet the same format and quality requirements.
    • Declarations and form: The required documents must be signed and uploaded in PDF format at the time of submission through the platform. The documents required for dossier contributions are available here, while those required for reviews are available here.
  • The Editorial Committee will then conduct a formal evaluation of the submission within fifty (50) calendar days of receipt. If omissions or non-compliance with the established requirements are identified, the submission will be returned to the author, who will be asked to address the comments before the process can continue. The author will have ten (10) days to make the required corrections. The editorial evaluation will consider the submission’s thematic relevance, originality, academic contribution, and conformity with the journal’s editorial scope. This evaluation does not constitute peer review. If the document meets the established criteria, it will be accepted. Otherwise, the author will be notified of the rejection, and the submission file will be closed.
  • Dossier contributions and reviews approved by the Editorial Committee will proceed to the editorial production stage, which includes copyediting to check spelling, grammar, and syntax, as well as clarity of presentation. The Editorial Committee will have a maximum of fifty (50) calendar days to complete copyediting. Authors must then address the comments within a maximum of ten (10) calendar days.
  • Finally, once all comments have been addressed and the final version of the manuscript has been approved, the layout and typesetting stage will begin, followed by publication on OJS in accordance with the journal’s editorial guidelines and formatting requirements. This stage will take a maximum of sixty (60) calendar days. The manuscript will then be available for consultation and dissemination.